Copies of a Copy

In 2007, an investment firm hired my studio, ERA404, to design an “Indiana Jones diary” for a global investor, as a unique way of showcasing their findings from a literacy study they conducted. Part of the project was creating a dozen or so original illustrations from his travels. One of the illustrations was of Huckleberry Finn rafting down the Mississippi River. I confess that I borrowed inspiration from an iconic book cover when creating the artwork.

"Huck Finn River" Google Search ResultsA few weeks ago, a friend and colleague pointed my attention to an article on which incorporated a cropped version of this illustration. On a whim, I did a Google Image Search, and was able to find that this image has been reproduced, re-cropped, and re-used in 8 pages and 90 links worth of results, making it one of the most frequently returned images in Google searches with the keywords “huck finn river”.

Now, I know I’m probably not entitled to brag about this. The original illustrator of the Huckleberry Finn book cover deserves that credit. However, I find it fascinating how contagious image reproduction can be, online, and wonder how many users my illustration has reached over the last eight years. I’ve always believed that an artist—commercial or fine—assimilates pre-existing works and the defining difference between plagiarism and inspiration is the point of departure. Does the piece build upon or contrast with the concept from the original? Does it contribute to the theme or provide an alternate perspective to the viewer? Does it stand on its own without requiring reference to the original?

I like to believe my interpretation of the iconic scene is more inspiration than plagiarism. I’m curious what you think of this illustration and the way it has been reused in the 24 applications, below.

2 Replies to “Copies of a Copy

  1. Which colleague was this? You should provide a link to his LinkedIn profile or something. He sounds quite resourceful! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *